Go to page 1, 2
  Forum » General » buy-train-sell back to the same team Date
Username
163 msgs.
Substitute
 hello everybody....i'm training GK in my junior team. there is a guy that want to loan his GK to me to train him. but i have already 3 loaned players. can i buy him now at a similar tranf. price,train him all the season and at the end of the season sell him back to that guy at his new similar transf.price?? or we will be banned??i think there is nothing illegal in this, but can anyone tell me at sure?? 05/10/2013 20:27
  - Div/Gr
Username
2897 msgs.
Best scorer
 I'm not a fiscal, so I don't dole out punishments, but my opinion of your situation is that you are using a round trip transaction to subvert the 3 player loan limit, which would be a violation of game rule 9:

http://en.strikermanager.com/wiki/index.php?title=NORMAS_DE_USO

If any fiscal wants to clarify (or correct me), please do.

Edited by @sabrefan62 05-10-2013 20:37 		05/10/2013 20:32
  - Div/Gr
Username
163 msgs.
Substitute
 ok...thanx for the information!...i think that i shoudnt make this deal...i dont have any real benifit anyway! 05/10/2013 21:08
  - Div/Gr
Username
1117 msgs.
International
 round trip transactions are illegal... even though some higher "powered" managers bend the rules and do it... get away with it saying it has been 3 seasons or more, or selling to another manager, then the other manager sells to another and then back to original owner... corruption...

 06/10/2013 00:56
  - Div/Gr
Username
5339 msgs.
Golden Ball
rabioso01 said:

+1 		06/10/2013 03:21
  A - Div2/Gr4
Username
163 msgs.
Substitute
 thnx for the information my friends! 06/10/2013 04:57
  - Div/Gr
Username
4993 msgs.
Best scorer
rabioso01 said:
round trip transactions are illegal... even though some higher "powered" managers bend the rules and do it... get away with it saying it has been 3 seasons or more, or selling to another manager, then the other manager sells to another and then back to original owner... corruption...



hmm. I wonder wHo you Can be talking about? 		09/10/2013 10:55
  - Div/Gr
4213 msgs.
Best scorer
@sabrefan62 said:
I'm not a fiscal, so I don't dole out punishments, but my opinion of your situation is that you are using a round trip transaction to subvert the 3 player loan limit, which would be a violation of game rule 9:

http://en.strikermanager.com/wiki/index.php?title=NORMAS_DE_USO

If any fiscal wants to clarify (or correct me), please do.

Edited by @sabrefan62 05-10-2013 20:37

i'm Confused @sabrefan (Fiscal) ? ;-P
Congrats. 		09/10/2013 11:29
  - Div/Gr
Username
2897 msgs.
Best scorer
 I was offered fiscal the next day.

So yes, I am now a fiscal (so watch out Jurgen ) 		09/10/2013 11:47
  - Div/Gr
Username
5569 msgs.
Golden Ball
supersonic84 said:
hello everybody....i'm training GK in my junior team. there is a guy that want to loan his GK to me to train him. but i have already 3 loaned players. can i buy him now at a similar tranf. price,train him all the season and at the end of the season sell him back to that guy at his new similar transf.price?? or we will be banned??i think there is nothing illegal in this, but can anyone tell me at sure??


Round trip yes.

If you keep a player for a long time then want to sell back.... You should have a basically equal player on your squad.

If i take a 14 yo... Then 3 seasons later he is 65/17...if i have 2 youth same position same average then it really doesn't make a bit of difference.

Just give some heads up.

My preference would be to sell the other, equal player back. And that it would be an rt transfer...and it is fairly straightforward matter to tell if it was the intention from the start.

The fuzziness occurs when you have sold a great player to a pl mate or whatnot. Then 3-4 seasons later he is great AND you happen to be in the market AND that person is only one willing to sell.

That's why we're judges to judge this stuff 		10/10/2013 02:46
  - Div/Gr
     
Go to page 1, 2
1